All Guides
Banks

BRAVE for Community Banks

How community banks can adopt the BRAVE appraisal standard. Covers implementation steps, required fields, and benefits for smaller CRE lenders.

Why Community Banks Should Adopt BRAVE

Community banks — typically defined as institutions with under $10 billion in assets — often process commercial real estate appraisals manually. A loan officer reads the PDF, re-keys the critical figures into the loan origination system, and an underwriter checks the numbers. This process is slow, error-prone, and expensive relative to the bank's staffing levels.

The BRAVE standard offers community banks a way to automate the ingestion of appraisal data without building custom integrations or investing in enterprise-grade systems. Because BRAVE is an open, standardized format, it works with any loan origination system that can import structured data.

Getting Started with BRAVE at a Community Bank

Adopting BRAVE does not require a massive technology overhaul. Most community banks can begin accepting BRAVE files in three steps:

Step 1: Update Your Appraiser Engagement Letters

Add a requirement that appraisals be delivered with a BRAVE-format data file (XLSX) in addition to the standard PDF report. BRAVE — created by Valcre as an open industry standard — has 99 fields in 6 categories (Job, Property, Income, Value, Appraiser). Specify which fields are most important based on your loan types. For a baseline set of requirements, see our BRAVE Compliance Checklist.

Step 2: Configure Your Loan Origination System

Most modern LOS platforms can import CSV or XLSX data. Work with your vendor to map BRAVE fields to your system's data fields. The core mappings typically include:

  • Property address and type (Property.AddressStreet, Property.AddressCity, Property.Type) to your collateral record
  • Reconciled final value (Value.ReconciledFinal) to the appraised value field
  • NOI (Income.NetOperatingIncome) and cap rate (Value.CapRate) to your underwriting worksheet
  • Value date (Value.Date) to the appraisal date field

Step 3: Validate Incoming BRAVE Files

Not every appraiser will deliver a perfect BRAVE file on the first try. Set up a validation step — either manual or automated — to check incoming files for completeness and accuracy. Tools like AppraisalAPI.com can validate BRAVE files against the specification and flag missing or malformed fields before the data enters your system.

Which BRAVE Fields Matter Most for Community Banks

Community banks typically focus on a narrower set of BRAVE fields than large national lenders. The essential fields for most community bank CRE loans are:

  • Property fields: Property.Name, Property.AddressStreet through Property.AddressPostalCode, Property.Type, and Property.LegalDescription.
  • Value fields: Value.ReconciledFinal, Value.Date, Value.IncomeApproach, Value.SalesApproach, Value.CostApproach.
  • Income fields: For income-producing properties, Income.NetOperatingIncome, Income.EffectiveGrossIncome, and Income.OperatingExpenses are critical for debt service coverage calculations.
  • Appraiser fields: Appraiser.Name and Appraiser.LicenseNum for regulatory compliance.

Note: BRAVE does not include comparable sales fields. Comp data remains in the PDF report narrative.

You do not need to require every BRAVE field for every appraisal. Tailor your requirements to your loan types and risk appetite.

Benefits Beyond Efficiency

Adopting BRAVE delivers benefits beyond faster data entry:

Regulatory preparedness. Examiners increasingly expect banks to demonstrate data governance around collateral valuation. BRAVE provides an auditable, structured record of appraisal data.

Portfolio analytics. Once appraisal data is in structured form, community banks can analyze cap rate trends, value-per-unit benchmarks, and expense ratios across their portfolio — capabilities previously available only to larger institutions.

Appraiser accountability. BRAVE files make it easy to spot appraisals with missing data or internal inconsistencies, improving the quality of work from your approved appraiser panel.

For banks ready to take the next step, our BRAVE for Regional Banks guide covers more advanced implementation patterns, including API-based ingestion and automated underwriting workflows. For background on why the industry is moving toward structured data, read why banks require BRAVE and see how Bank OZK's mandate set the standard.

Convert your appraisals to BRAVE

Upload a PDF and get all 99 BRAVE fields extracted automatically.

Try It Free